QUOTE
Originally posted by owow_ramone:
since when has slipknot, glassjaw and hatebreed been considered PUNK?!?!?
i would have to agree that slipknot is, has not beeen, and will never be punk.
HOWEVER, you're dead wrong about glassjaw and hatebreed. punk, you see, has a lot of sub-genres, two of which are emo and hardcore. yes, emo punk and hardcore punk.
now, glassjaw falls under the first category. they're emo, and that is a fact that you have to digest. on the other hand, there's hatebreed, which, contrary to your assertion, is still punk for the very reason that they make hardcore music.
QUOTE
hatebreed is loosley categorized as hardcore, glassjaw emo-core (or whatever) and slipknot new metal. hotugh some of these bands may have incorporated little elements of punk in thier music, they are not in any way, PUNK.
hah! excuse me, but what exactly makes hatebreed and glassjaw soooooo un-punk? :eek: if hardcore and emo "are" so devoid of "punkness," then why the fart are these genres called hardcore PUNK and emo PUNK in the first place? :mad:
am very sorry to glean that you've got a crude understanding of punk and its sub-genres. i thought that you knew what you were talking about, but then i've proven myself wrong. anyhow, hardcore and emo have incorporated elements of punk, although not as insignificant as you think.
i think this is worth reading. i posted this in peyups too. i authored this. do read, so you'd at least have a GOOD GRASP of hardcore PUNK. oh, and yes, hardcore PUNK.
hardcore is an offshoot of the punk movement. it began towards the end of the 70s in the US, but gained a considerable number of following in the early 80s. the most prominent bands are minor threat, black flag, bad brains, suicidal tendencies, agnostic front, the ex, and sick of it all, to name a few.
hardcore is a sub-genre of punk, though some people claim to have difficulty in tracing the "punkness" of these bands. this could be due to the fact that punk rock at that time, has been largely defined in terms of the clash and the pistols' material. the thing is, hardcore is more aggressive musically and politically. they are heavier and more intense than classic punk. they are usually characterized by stop-and-go rythms, heavy and steady beating of the drums, harsh vocals that almost never sing. it's really, really fast. in some cases, you won't even understand the words that are being blurted out.
the most definitive attribute of hardcore is its social activism. hc is more than music. it is politically-charged punk. hardcore is the most highly-politicized genre of music that i know of. people who are part of the movement openly combat all forms of oppression (racism, sexism, fascism, etc.), and this is highly evident in their lyrics.
hc is way different from the early punk scene, where pessimistic and anarchic attitudes reigned supreme. people used punk rock as their medium of protest against the pervasive societal ills at that time, but what exactly did they do to create a better society? they were critics, who did a great job of tongue-lashing, but were nevertheless distanced from the purest sense of political activism.
QUOTE
[B]
alot of punk/ pop-punk bands have been coming out latley. such as a simply plan (YUCK!), goodcharlotte (posers), and sum41.
teka lang ah. it's gettting soooo obvious that you seem horribly unsure of what you're mercilessly babbling about.
yes, simple plan and sum41 are relatively new in the scene (circa 01-03) but compared to the other two who sprung up like fungi, good charlotte's been in the industry since 99. okay, they're not old school and everything, but you see, they have not enjoyed this mainstream popularity until this year. heck, four years, or even a year ago, the pop-loving people never even knew of their existence, but now.. oh my.. everyone who watches mtv or myx or ch v or whathaveyou knows about these guys. they're actually okay COMPARED to sum41 and simple plan. well, i don't like whiney lil boys singing about trivialities, 'coz i listen to old school straightedge hardcore PUNK (that's P-U-N-K) and old school straightedge emo PUNK (oh here: P-U-N-K) ala fugazi and faith.
QUOTE
[B]
locally, there are punk bands rocking the scene sucha as HUH!, BoyElroy, The Betrayed and Throw.
uh, betrayed is old school. since i don't listen to nu, i don't know if they're getting airplay. nevertheless, they're one of the classic punk bands in the philippines.
APIR.TAYO.DAMING.POSEUR.NAGKALAT.NAKAKATAKOT.NAKAKAMATAY.